Request a demo

InsightsArticles

The Hidden Cost of Running Out

Explores why inventory decisions should account for both the visible costs of carrying stock and the less obvious financial consequences of running out of critical materials. It examines how companies can improve resilience and capital efficiency by targeting inventory where it provides the greatest operational protection and considering ways to fund early purchases without committing corporate cash too soon.

Close-up of microchips on a dark blue circuit board, one small part glowing amber

Inventory is expensive. It ties up working capital, incurs storage and handling costs, and exposes companies to damage, deterioration and obsolescence. These costs are visible in financial statements and working capital reports, making inventory a natural target when finance teams look for ways to improve efficiency.

The cost of not having inventory is less obvious. It emerges when a missing component interrupts production, a shipment is delayed, or a supplier cannot deliver materials when they are needed. A relatively inexpensive part can hold up an entire production line, while the financial consequences extend well beyond the cost of replacing it.

This creates a fundamental challenge for CFOs. The cost of carrying inventory is measurable today, while the value of inventory that prevents a future disruption is largely counterfactual. It exists in the shutdown that never happened, the customer delivery that was fulfilled, or the time gained to find an alternative supplier.

Two costs, only one of them on the report

Carrying inventory: visible

  • Working capital tied up
  • Storage and handling
  • Damage, deterioration and obsolescence

Running out: hidden

  • Idle equipment and labor
  • Delayed customer deliveries
  • Expedited shipments and emergency sourcing
  • Contractual penalties, lost sales, strained relationships

Minimize the combined cost of carrying inventory and operating without it.

The objective should not be to minimize inventory at all costs. It should be to minimize the combined cost of carrying inventory and operating without it.

When a missing component becomes a financial problem

Supply chain disruptions rarely affect only the purchase price of the missing material. Their consequences can spread across the business.

A shortage may idle equipment and labor, reduce production, delay customer deliveries, and require expensive emergency shipments or alternative sourcing. Companies may need to reschedule production, pay for expedited materials or absorb contractual penalties. If customers cannot wait, a temporary supply problem can become a lost sale or damage a commercial relationship.

These costs can compound. A manufacturer that cannot complete a product may lose the contribution margin it would otherwise have earned while still carrying many of the fixed costs associated with production. The longer the interruption lasts, the harder it can become to recover lost output. A delayed delivery may also disrupt a customer’s own operations, creating consequences beyond the original transaction.

Not every disruption results in permanently lost sales. Some orders are delayed and fulfilled later, and some production can be recovered through overtime or revised schedules. But recovery itself can be expensive, and the financial consequences can extend beyond the period in which the shortage occurred.

Research suggests these effects can be substantial. In a 2005 study published in Management Science, Kevin Hendricks and Vinod Singhal compared 885 publicly announced supply chain glitches with firms of similar size and industry. Relative to the comparison firms, companies experiencing glitches had 6.92 percent lower sales growth, 10.66 percent higher cost growth and 13.88 percent higher inventory growth. The researchers also found that operating income, sales, costs and inventory did not quickly recover during the two years following the announcements. These findings describe an association between supply chain problems and weaker operating performance, rather than a precise estimate of the cost of any single stockout. [1]

After 885 announced supply chain glitches, against comparable firms [1]
6.92 percent
lower sales growth
10.66 percent
higher cost growth
13.88 percent
higher inventory growth

The implication for CFOs is important. A supply disruption can affect revenue, operating costs and inventory at the same time. Evaluating inventory solely through its carrying cost risks overlooking the broader financial exposure it helps manage.

The lesson from the semiconductor shortage

The automotive semiconductor shortage of 2021 and 2022 illustrates how a relatively small component can have an outsized effect on production.

Modern vehicles rely on semiconductors for numerous functions, but chips are not always interchangeable. A shortage of one type can constrain production even when other components and production capacity are available. Automakers cannot necessarily replace an unavailable chip without engineering changes, testing and qualification.

S&P Global Mobility estimated that semiconductor shortages reduced global light vehicle production by more than 9.5 million units in 2021, with another 3 million units affected in 2022. These are estimates of production losses relative to expected output, not a count of permanently lost vehicle sales. Even so, they illustrate the scale of production exposed to shortages of critical inputs. [2]

A September 2026 analysis by the Federal Reserve reached a similar conclusion for US vehicle production. Output fell about 20 percent below its late-2020 level by the third quarter of 2021 and did not return to that baseline until early 2023. The cumulative production shortfall exceeded 2 million vehicles over 2021 and 2022. The authors also found that lead times for some microcontrollers roughly doubled, from 15 to 30 weeks. [3]

The semiconductor shortage, by the estimates
9.5 million+
units: the estimated reduction in global light vehicle production in 2021, with another 3 million affected in 2022S&P Global Mobility [2]
2 million+
cumulative US vehicle production shortfall over 2021 and 2022Federal Reserve [3]
15 → 30 weeks
lead times for some microcontrollers, roughly doubledFederal Reserve [3]

The lesson is not that every manufacturer should have stockpiled semiconductors. The shortage was shaped by unusual demand patterns, production constraints and the technical complexity of the semiconductor supply chain. Holding inventory also carries the risk of buying the wrong components or committing capital to materials that later become unnecessary.

The broader lesson is that a component’s economic importance cannot be assessed by its purchase price alone. Its value also depends on the production and revenue it enables. When a difficult-to-replace component can stop an entire production process, the financial exposure associated with running out may be many times greater than the cost of holding additional supply.

Measuring the value of inventory protection

Inventory carrying costs are relatively straightforward to calculate. They include the cost of capital tied up in stock, warehousing, insurance, handling and the risk of obsolescence. Finance teams can monitor these costs and track improvements in inventory turns and days inventory outstanding.

The value of preventing a disruption is harder to measure because it depends on an uncertain alternative. If a company carries an additional three weeks of a critical component and never experiences a shortage, the buffer may appear unnecessary in hindsight. But the absence of a disruption does not prove the inventory had no value. The buffer may have reduced the consequences of a supplier delay or protected the company against an event that never occurred.

This creates an imbalance in routine financial decisions. The carrying cost appears every reporting period, while the benefit of protection may never appear as a distinct line item. Inventory reduction can therefore look like an unambiguous improvement even when it increases operational risk.

The opposite mistake is equally costly. Companies can overestimate the protection provided by additional stock, particularly when demand changes quickly, products become obsolete, or the underlying disruption affects logistics and production capacity rather than inventory availability. Extra inventory is not automatically resilience.

A more useful approach is to evaluate inventory against the specific risk it is intended to mitigate. CFOs and procurement leaders should consider the likelihood of a shortage, how long it could last, the time required to qualify alternative suppliers or components, and the financial consequences of interrupted production. They should also assess how much additional inventory would actually reduce that exposure.

Weigh a buffer against the risk it is meant to cover
  1. How likely is a shortage?
  2. How long could it last?
  3. How long would it take to qualify alternative suppliers or components?
  4. What would interrupted production cost?
  5. How much would additional inventory actually reduce that exposure?

For example, a company might compare the expected financial impact of a shortage with the cost of holding an additional buffer. That assessment should account for the probability of disruption, the potential operating and financial impact, and the extent to which the buffer would reduce that impact. The result will not be perfectly precise, but it provides a more disciplined basis for deciding where additional inventory is justified.

The analysis should also distinguish between critical and replaceable materials. A component with a long replenishment lead time and no practical substitute may warrant a buffer that would be difficult to justify for a widely available commodity. Inventory that buys several weeks to secure alternative supply may be valuable. Inventory that cannot address the underlying disruption may not be.

Critical or replaceable?

Critical material

  • Long replenishment lead time
  • No practical substitute
  • A buffer may be warranted

Replaceable material

  • A widely available commodity
  • Can be replaced quickly
  • A buffer is harder to justify

The objective is to direct capital toward materials where it provides the greatest operational protection, rather than increasing stock indiscriminately.

Securing inventory without committing capital too early

Even when a company concludes that it should secure inventory earlier, another decision remains: how should the purchase be funded?

Consider a manufacturer that wants to purchase critical materials from an existing supplier three months before production. Procurement believes early purchasing will reduce the risk of a shortage. Operations wants the materials available on schedule. Finance would prefer to keep its cash available for other priorities rather than pay for inventory that will sit unused.

The operational decision and the financing decision are related, but they do not have to be the same. The company may have a sound reason to secure materials early without wanting to commit its own capital at the moment of purchase.

This is where inventory financing can provide another option. Through its Capital as a Service model, 1TCC funds agreed inventory purchases from a customer’s existing suppliers. The customer continues to select suppliers, negotiate prices and manage its established procurement relationships. The inventory remains in the customer’s existing warehouse or third-party logistics network, so the physical supply chain does not need to change.

1TCC purchases and owns the agreed inventory, and the customer takes the materials for consumption under the contractual terms. Payment is scheduled according to those terms, which can allow the customer to pay after the materials have been used rather than committing its cash when the supplier is paid.

Securing supply early, paying later
  1. Customer choosesSelects suppliers, negotiates prices, keeps the relationships.
  2. 1TCC purchases and ownsThe agreed inventory, from the existing supplier.
  3. Existing warehouse or 3PLThe physical supply chain does not need to change.
  4. Use, then payPayment can fall after the materials have been used.

Materials

Cash, later

This separates the decision to secure supply from the timing of the customer’s own cash commitment. Procurement can purchase materials when availability or lead times justify doing so, while finance retains capital for other priorities during the period before payment is due.

The service carries a fee, so it should be evaluated against the operational protection it provides, the duration of the funding, and alternatives such as internal cash, revolving credit, asset-based lending or supplier payment terms. It does not create additional supply, eliminate inventory risk or make every early purchase economically attractive. Its value depends on whether the benefits of securing inventory and retaining cash justify the total cost.

If the risk of a shortage is low, or the inventory can be replaced quickly, early purchasing may not make sense. If a shortage could interrupt a high-value production process and alternatives are limited, securing inventory may be economically rational even when it carries a cost. In those situations, the ability to fund the purchase without immediately committing corporate cash can make the decision easier to support.

Optimize the cost of inventory and the cost of being without it

Strong working capital management remains essential. Inventory that is unnecessary, poorly positioned or likely to become obsolete consumes resources without providing sufficient protection. But reducing inventory is not always the same as reducing the company’s overall risk-adjusted costs.

The most effective companies will evaluate inventory in the context of the operations it supports. They will identify materials that could constrain production, assess the financial consequences of a shortage, and compare the cost of protection with the exposure it reduces. They will also consider whether the funding structure allows them to secure critical materials without unnecessarily limiting other uses of corporate capital.

The best inventory decision protects the company’s ability to operate while making the most efficient use of its capital.

The best inventory decision is not necessarily the one that minimizes stock or the one that minimizes its direct cost. It is the one that protects the company’s ability to operate while making the most efficient use of its capital.

Research references

  1. Hendricks and Singhal, “Association Between Supply Chain Glitches and Operating Performance,” Management Science (2005).
  2. S&P Global Mobility, “The Semiconductor Shortage Is Mostly Over for the Auto Industry” (July 2023).
  3. Federal Reserve, “When the Chips Went Down: Motor Vehicle Production and the 2021–2022 Semiconductor Shortages” (September 28, 2026).

More from our deep experience

Explore how your inventory can support your next strategic initiative.

Request a demo